We score every major sportsbook, exchange, and prediction market on three axes:
- Average vig — round-trip margin on a representative basket of NFL/NBA/MLB markets.
- Line speed — moves per hour on those same markets, normalized for liquidity.
- Sharp tolerance — qualitative: do they limit known winners?
The composite is rescaled to 0–100. Pinnacle anchors at 98 by definition; everyone else falls out from there.
Reading the chart
The top four — Pinnacle, Circa, BetCRIS, Sporttrade — form the "fair line" cohort. For most of BettingLab's EV calls, this is where the consensus comes from. The retail tier (FanDuel, DraftKings, Caesars, BetMGM) clusters in the high 60s to low 70s.
The gap matters. A 25-point sharpness gap implies a 2-3% edge available on average, which is exactly the EV band our scanner reports.
Methodology notes
- Sample window: trailing 30 days through 2026-04-30.
- Markets: NFL spread/total, NBA spread/total, MLB moneyline/total.
- Liquidity normalization: line moves are weighted by observed handle proxies.
- DFS pick'em operators are scored separately and are not included here.
We refresh this leaderboard quarterly. Edge subscribers via Juiced see the underlying per-market breakdowns.